The Dinner Game

The Dinner Game is a lovely French comedy about a rich publishing house owner, Pierre Brochant, who indulges in cruel rich man's games which involve making fun of others. He and a few of his friends organize a dinner every wednesday, and each of them bring with them an "idiot", the dumbest and weirdest person they can find. They then spend the entire evening covertly making fun of these poor people who think that they have been honoured by being invited to a dinner with such influential people.

The movie starts with the publishing house owner recruiting a new idiot, Francois Pignon, a guy who is extremely passionate about making buildings and structures with matchsticks. However, the evening that they are supposed to go to the dinner, Monsieur Brochant hurts his back. Pignon shows up at his house, and just as he is about to leave, Brochant not being in any state to go to the dinner, Brochant's wife calls, saying that she is leaving Brochant. Pignon stays back to help Brochant to bed, and hence begins the comedy of errors. The movie highlights how Brochant, from being the rich man condescending to help Pignon publish a book on his structures, goes to recruiting Pignon's help to discovering his wife's whereabouts. All throughout, Pignon, being the well-meaning idiot he is, tries to help Brochant, but ends up complicating things more. He calls Brochant's mistress and tells her that his wife has left him, turns away Brochant's wife thinking that she is the mistress, invites the mistress into the house thinking that she is the wife, etc. etc. The icing on the cake is at the end, when he tries to do a last good deed for Brochant by calling his wife and telling her how much Brochant loves her, and that this is not being dictated by Brochant but that he is speaking from a payphone. Brochant's wife melts and says that she will consider calling Brochant. Brochant is extremely grateful, and realizing the error of his ways, promises to never call anyone an idiot again. However, the very next minute, when Brochant's wife calls, Pignon answers the phone, and causes Brochant to break his promise.

The movie is extremely well made. The actors are both wonderful and have played their part to perfection. L'hermitte comes across very well as a jaded rich philanderer, while Villeret plays the dumb tax inspector with a passion for football and matchstick structures to a T. As with every good movie, one gets caught up in the narrative and extremely frustrated with the stupidity of the Pignon character. The movie had me pulling on my hair with frustration every time Pignon pulled a trick. At the same time, I could not help laughing at his antics. All in all, the movie is a lovely light-hearted comedy, which I would recommend to everyone.

Before I saw this movie, I had seen its Indian version, Bheja Fry. At that time, I had loved Bheja Fry because of the story. However, Bheja Fry pales in comparison to this movie, due to the wonderful acting by the actors in the original, and also due to the fact that Bheja Fry is pretty much a scene for scene remake of The Dinner Game. Thus, some jokes which work in the French context do not do so well in the Indian, and also some of the story background (like the leading character's having a mistress) does not fit in well with the normal Indian culture. I must say that although I was disappointed that Indian directors still resort to blatant copying of foreign films, I am glad that atleast now they are being a little better about choosing which films to rip off.